The recent Supreme Court decision on car finance mis-selling has sparked headlines, confusion, and hope for compensation among millions of UK motorists. With financial expert Martin Lewis weighing in, it’s crucial to understand what the ruling means in practical terms, who is affected, and how the path to compensation will unfold. Here’s an in-depth exploration of the ruling, the issues at stake, and best steps for UK consumers as explained by the country’s most trusted money-saving guru.
Understanding Discretionary Commission Arrangements
At the heart of the issue are “discretionary commission arrangements” (DCAs), a now-banned practice that allowed car dealers and brokers to adjust the interest rate on car finance agreements. The higher the rate, the more commission the broker or dealer received—an incentive not disclosed to consumers at the time. The Financial Conduct Authority (FCA) estimates this arrangement affected up to 40% of car finance agreements in the UK between 2007 and January 2021, covering both personal contract purchase (PCP) and hire purchase schemes.
The Supreme Court Ruling: Limiting the Scope
On 1 August 2025, the Supreme Court issued its ruling on the legality of secret commission payments within car finance deals. The verdict reversed a 2024 Court of Appeal decision that had threatened to unleash tens of billions of pounds in compensation claims against banks and lenders. The justices found that, except for extreme cases where commissions were excessive or linked to DCAs, lenders were generally not required to compensate consumers for undisclosed payments to brokers and dealers. The Court ruled that car dealers did not have a fiduciary duty to their customers beyond commercial interests—a key point for industry figures who breathed a sigh of relief.
However, the verdict was not an outright win for lenders. The judgment kept open compensation for cases where commissions clearly led to unfairly high interest rates or other forms of consumer detriment—essentially, instances involving DCAs.
The FCA’s Role: Consultation and Compensation Scheme
After the ruling, the FCA announced it will launch a formal consultation in October 2025 to shape a redress scheme for those affected by DCAs and similar egregious practices. Payments are expected from 2026 onwards, and the scheme is designed to be as simple as possible—with the FCA keen to ensure that drivers do not need to use costly claims management companies, which could charge up to 30% in fees.
Martin Lewis’s Key Advice for UK Consumers
Martin Lewis, founder of MoneySavingExpert, has provided clear direction for those who may qualify. He stresses that compensation for most people will be “hundreds, not thousands, of pounds”—up to around £950 per agreement, with higher amounts possible only for drivers who took out multiple finance deals. Lewis urges consumers:
Check if your agreement included a discretionary commission. This may be noted in your original loan paperwork or you can contact your finance provider for details.
Don’t rush to use claims firms or lawyers; the forthcoming FCA scheme is designed to be easy to access without paid representation.
If you believe you overpaid due to a DCA and want to act now, you can complain directly to your finance provider. If no resolution is offered, you have the right to take your case to the Financial Ombudsman.
Who Could Receive Compensation?
The FCA and Martin Lewis agree that motorists who bought cars using PCP or hire purchase agreements before 28 January 2021 could be in line for payments—if their deals included DCAs or similar arrangements that resulted in unfair interest rates. Those who have already raised complaints can expect updates as the scheme progresses. For others, it’s best to wait for FCA guidance rather than risk losing a portion of any redress by signing up with a private claims firm.
The Wider Economic Picture
While the Supreme Court’s decision limits the compensation bill for lenders (once estimated as high as £45 billion, now closer to £18 billion or less), banks and finance houses still face significant liabilities. Major institutions such as Lloyds have set aside billions to cover anticipated payouts. The FCA has made it clear that, where consumer harm is established, compensation is both fair and necessary—and that lenders will be required to reach out proactively to eligible customers when the scheme is finalised.
Looking Ahead – What UK Motorists Should Expect
The road to compensation may seem slow, with the FCA’s process taking until at least late 2026 for most payments to arrive. However, the scheme aims to provide a fair, efficient route to redress for consumers wronged by hidden commissions, without forcing them to pay fees or navigate legal complexities.
Martin Lewis’s guidance is simple: be patient, document your car finance deals where possible, and avoid paid claims firms. With scrutiny on the financial sector as never before, this Supreme Court decision reaffirms the continuing importance of transparent lending—and the power of consumer action, informed by trusted voices, to shape outcomes in the UK’s finance markets.
Read more; Brock Lesnar